Due to recent changes by familytreedna in the way we are allowed to obtain the dna data of our project participants, significant changes to our software will be required to obtain any new or updated data. Stephens now what, brent lee metcalfes reinventing lamanite identity, and thomas murphy s inventing galileo, in sunstone, march 2004, as well as robert prices joseph smith in the book of mormon dialogue. The class, cotaught with biologist jenny mcfarland, is. A number of investigators have used genetic and blood testing studies to show that native americans are related closely to the inhabitants of siberia. Dna and the book of mormon brigham young university. The anthon transcript is a small piece of paper on which joseph smith wrote several lines of characters. I purchased over 50 copies of this dvd and sent them to mormon temples in the united states and abroad. However, this attack ignores several key points, among which is the fact that the book of mormon states that lehi and his family are clearly not jews. If there is no genetic marker that can identify a person as a jew, i would ask thomas murphy and other critics of the book of mormon exactly what dna evidence we should be looking for to test the hypothesis that a tiny handful of hebrew people entered the americas in 600 b. A subreddit for community of christ, formerly known as rlds. Jul 04, 2005 dna and the book of mormon modern jewish vs. The controversy arises from dna studies of native american peoples.
Murphy born circa 1967 is an american anthropologist and writer. Dna lamanites book of mormon genetics genealogy genesis. Edmonds community college learn and serve environmental anthropology field leaf school. Attacks on the validity of the book of mormon using dna data support for the book of mormon by mormon academics. The book of mormon claims that the native american peoples are descended from the house of israel, but the dna evidence, according to this book, points to an asiatic origin for the american continents native people. While critics may believe that book of mormon dna testing entirely undermines mormon beliefs, it is important to realize that some underlying assumptions may have lead to faulty conclusions. Murphy discusses the book of mormon s claim that american indians are descendants of ancient hebrews, despite recent dna tests indicating that native americans descended from siberian ancestry and not from jewish or middle eastern descent. It was a total coincidence that, in 2006, the introduction to. As clearly shown by those scientists used in the video, see thomas murphy s article in the book american apocrypha, simon southertons book losing a lost tribe, and trent stephens book evolution and mormonism, all these works by these three used in the video demonstrates that dna has helped confirm evolution using that exact same. Nov 14, 20 dna and the book of mormon by 99 dna and the book of mormon david g. The book of mormon, one of the four books of scripture of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints see standard works, is an account of three groups of people. I crossed paths with this dvd and with the bible vs.
The book of mormon for more than 170 years, the church of jesus christ of latterday saints has declared the book of mormon to be a scriptural and literal history. Native americans dna, and the mormon church, signature books, 2004, which gives a more complete accounting of the current status of polynesians and native americans in context with national. The largest genealogical group out there is the mormon church, so fundamentally every genealogy company makes their software compatible with the churchs free familysearch site, tries to market to mormons, and at. Genetic data shows that the american indians are asian, and unrelated to white caucasians. His essay is titled, lamanite genesis, genealogy, and genetics. The following essay is the official lds released essay entitled book of mormon and dna studies. He addressed a book of mormon lands conference on 2007oct20 in salt lake city, ut. The traditional lds position the book of mormon recounts the story of small israelite groups headed by lehi and mulek that were brought from ancient jerusalem to the american continent by the hand of the lord. Lamanite genesis, genealogy, and genetics, by thomas w.
Would dna analysis show as taught by the book of mormon that. So my main question is about what rod meldrum and his association present as dna evidence that proves the book of mormon true. Thomas murphy, mormon anthropologist, american apocrypha, 2002, p. Claims of a limited geography or local colonization in mesoamerica do not save the book of mormon from genetic evidence. The class, cotaught with biologist jenny mcfarland, is on becoming human. Its the 5ton elephant in the room that researchers geneticist do not want to talk about. Murphy was subsequently summoned to an lds disciplinary council for apostasy.
Would dna analysis show as taught by the book of mormon that many american indians are descended from ancient israelites. Mormon, autobiography, church of jesus christ of latterday saints, anthropology, science, religion, excommunication, dna, book of mormon, child abuse, persian gulf war, racism, galileo 2. The biggest problem with most anti mormon attacks involving dna and the book of mormon is not so much the lack of scholarship about dna as it is the lack of scholarship concerning the book of mormon. And since the book of mormon is touted by lds church leadership as the keystone of the lds faith, once you remove the keystone, the entire structure crumbles. I also sent a copy to byu university, to farms, the mormons branch that is in charge of protecting mormon beliefs, asking how i could refute this dvd. Murphy born circa 1967 is a latter day saint anthropologist and writer. Book of mormon dna mormonism, the mormon church, beliefs. Thomas murphy uses the lemba as an example of a group proven to be jewish via dna testing. Murphy concluded that dna research lends no support to traditional mormon beliefs about the origins of native americans and he has likened the book of mormon to inspirational fiction.
Gardner professes that no study can change the truthfulness of the book. Essays on the book of mormon signature books, 2002. The conclusion states, much as critics and defenders of the book of mormon would like to use dna studies to support their views, the evidence is simply inconclusive. Blake ostlers errors it takes a lot of wishful thinkingto make dna lineages go away, by ron priddis mormon. Ancient israelite dna thomas murphy and some other critics suggest that the plausibility of claims of israelite ancestry by nonjewish groups can be assessed by measuring their dna affinity with modern jewish groups. Anthropologist thomas murphy on the book of mormon, dna. Murphy, 35, chairperson of the anthropology department at edmonds community college in lynnwood, wa went further. In my many and varied studies of mormon history, it is the science of dna and genetics that excites me most. Dna farms dna and the book of mormon, by cooper johnson does dna evidence refute the book of mormon. Attacks on the validity of the book of mormon using dna data dna studies by two investigators.
Jun 09, 2009 what makes his claims so intriguing is that he is a member of the mormon church. Does dna evidence prove the book of mormon to be false. According to smith, these characters were from the golden plates the ancient record from which smith claims to have translated the book of mormon and represent the reformed egyptian writing that was on the plates. Dna and a mesoamerican setting for the book of mormon. The thomas y dna project is currently not able to accept new members. We proclaim jesus christ and promote communities of joy, hope, love, and peace. Book of mormondna evidenceissues identifying ancient dna. Murphy insists that the book of mormon, touted by fellow members of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints mormons as the most correct book on earth, is incorrect when it claims that native americans are of jewish descent. It was a total coincidence that, in 2006, the introduction to the bom was changed from. Claims in recent years by lds anthropologist thomas murphy and former.
The lemba were identified as jewish because of a marker called the cohen modal haplotype. In 2002, anthropologist thomas murphy published an essay in which he argued that dna evidence points to native americans being related to asians, and therefore this disproves the book of mormon. Subtitled another testament of jesus christ, it recounts the story story. Simon is married to jane who is an english teacherlibrarian. Richard southerton, thomas murphy, joel kramer, jeremy reyes. Genetic genealogy eliminates two as descendants of joseph.
The book of mormon presents the evidence from dna researchers, including mormon scientists, who are wrestling with the dna dilemma that now faces mormonism. Mormon researchers such as anthropologist thomas w. Whiting, a prominent geneticist whose work has received widespread attention it was featured as the cover story in cover article in nature in midjanuary 2003, recently gave a lecture at byu entitled, does dna evidence refute the authenticity of the book of mormon. God did not neccessarily exclude people of other nationalities from becoming jewish or part of the tribes. Consider also this recent conclusion may, 2002 by thomas murphy that genetic research fails to show any connection between native americans and israelite dna. Essays on the book of mormon, edited by dan vogel and brent l. Before we begin to discuss book of mormon dna proofs and questions, here is an example that shows the difficulties in finding lamanite dna back to 600 b. Murphy posited that dna evidence suggests that native americans are descendants of.
Dna marker x2aj is probably the greatest dna evidence for the book of mormon thus far. The book of mormon recounts the story of small israelite groups led by lehi and mulek who were brought by the hand of the lord from ancient jerusalem to the american continent approximately 600 bc. The book of mormon suggest that there were no levites among the lehi party thomas murphy uses the lemba as an example of a group proven to be jewish via dna testing. Thomas murphy s essay is contained in american apocrypha. Murphy discusses the book of mormons claim that american indians are descendants of ancient hebrews, despite recent dna tests indicating that native americans descended from siberian ancestry and not from jewish or middle eastern descent. The scientific fact that native american dna evidence does not in any way support the literal history of the book of mormon destroys the credibility of the book of mormon. Prophets who taught of christ were called from among this people for over a millennium, but eventually the people fell. Claims in recent years by lds anthropologist thomas murphy and former lds molecular biologist simon southerton regarding the lack of genetic connection to hebrew blood have caused spirited debate in some quarters about the origin of the book of mormon, which church of jesus christ of latterday saints founder joseph smith said was translated. The ability of latterday saint scholars to repeat assertions of a limited geographic setting for the book of mormon should not be confused with actual scientific or historical evidence. From a scientific perspective, the bomors book of mormons origin is best situated in early 19th century america, not ancient america. Genetics and the book of mormon religionwiki fandom. Fundamental historical claims of the book of mormon are challenged by new genetic research.
Murphy set out to test a key principle of his mormon faith with the latest technology. May 11, 2009 a recently published book claims that dna evidence proves the book of mormon, one of the books of scripture used by the mormon church, incorrect. In lab class b212, murphy measures words as carefully as he measures the dark liquid squeezed into a petri dish. Thomas murphy, anthropologist, mormon scholar, and dna researcher, acknowledges the problem that the dna evidence presents for the historical accuracy of the book of mormon. The phone hasnt stopped ringing, says thomas murphy, the cultural. The book of mormon by richard southerton at a low price. On, a reader wrote in and complained that her native american ancestry did not show up in her dna test. Now when the mormons come knocking on my door i am armed with knowledge.
The conference is an annual event sponsored by the book of mormon archeological forum. While dna shows that ultimately all human populations are closely related, to date no intimate genetic link has been found between ancient israelites and indigenous americans, much less within the time frame suggested in the book of mormon. Genetic attacks on the book of mormon focus on the fact that amerindian dna seems closest to asian dna, and not dna from the middle east or jewish dna. Dna science challenges lds history christian research institute. It ties together incontrovertibly the more than 100 years of archaeological, anthropological and other science and humanities based evidences against the claimed historicity of the book of mormon. Some latterday saints have expressed optimism that dna research would lead to a vindication of the book of mormon as a translation of a genuine ancient document.
Devout mormon, daniel peterson, a professor of asian and near eastern languages at brigham young university, said. The idea that america may have been overwhelmingly peopled by folks. The book of mormon states ancient israelites came to the americas. On the erasure of native americans from the book of mormon. Murphy, 35yearold chairman of the edmonds community college anthropology department, contends dna analysis contradicts book of mormon claims that american indians are descended from ancient. The critics are using tentative scientific findings to discredit common misconceptions about the book of mormon, not what the text actually teaches. Dna science challenges lds history christian research. It was released by the church to help explain how the book of mormon s credibility is not harmed due to recent dna evidence which concludes that the native americans are not the descendants of the book of mormon people, and to explain why the churchs credibility is not harmed due to having such a. Researchers compare existing genetic evidence with the book of mormon story edit.
Dna claims rebutted on book of mormon deseret news. The ability of latterday saint scholars to repeat assertions of a limited geographic setting for the book of mormon should not be confused with actual scientific or historical evidence of an ancient origin. The book of mormon suggest that there were no levites among the lehi party. He criticized thomas murphy that the book of mormon is a piece of 19th century fiction. There is generally no support amongst mainstream historians and archaeologists for the historicity of the book of mormon. X2aj is not found in north america but its importance to native american dna is virtually unknown. Can the lemba and cohen modal haplotype associated with levite lineage be used to either prove or disprove the book of mormon. Thomas murphy on anthropology and book of mormon lamanite dna pt. Would dna analysis show as taught by the book of mormon that many. In 2004, plant biologist simon southerton published a book that made a similar argument. Thomas murphy should discuss some of these dna, cultural, linguistic, and artifact evidence. Murphy, lamanite genesis, genealogy, and genetics, in american apocrypha. Jun 21, 2016 in 2002 anthropologist thomas murphy, ph. What makes his claims so intriguing is that he is a member of the mormon church.
Thus, dna evidence indicates that the book of mormon is a fraud. The ultimate hypocrisy here is that he throws out personal speculation as fact that thomas murphy had already decided the book of mormon was fiction and was merely making conclusions to support this already decided belief. A recently published book claims that dna evidence proves that the book of mormon, a book of scripture used in conjunction with the bible by the mormon church, is incorrect and points to an asiatic origin versus a middle eastern origin for the inhabitants of the american continents. The book of mormon, first published by joseph smith, jr. Not only did joseph smith lie, so is the book of mormon.
826 1114 908 1231 1336 1346 187 3 184 1003 1186 714 406 1181 712 756 910 1233 215 1057 1431 335 1397 177 975 738 1489 530 608 684 772 1076 74 257 1320 106 179 172 210 380